Landlord charges every tenant a flat $500 move-out cleaning fee for years, hits 3 families at once, they group, sue together, and win every cent back plus legal fees: ‘We stood our ground. We filed a collective action, and yesterday we won’

Charging every single tenant a flat $500 cleaning fee on the way out, no matter what condition the apartment is in, is not a policy. It is a hustle with a paper trail.

Now I know a personal story doesn't exactly count as good news, but with how rare good news is today. Why don't we just agree that it wouldn't hurt to hear a story of tenants receiving(!) money from property managers and landlords. Thank you very much. This day already feels a little better now.

This whole thing works because moving is already a nightmare. You are coordinating a truck, a new deposit, overlapping leases, a change of address on seventeen different accounts, and somewhere in the middle of all that, a landlord slides in a charge that feels wrong but not wrong enough to blow up your entire schedule over. Five hundred dollars is a lot of money. It is also a lot of money to spend lawyering up to get five hundred dollars back. Corporate property managers know this math better than anyone. The fee exists because the fee works.

Like what you see? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google. 

Author image for Etai Eshet Etai Eshet
Add as a preferred
source on Google
Advertisement
  • Group of adults wearing jackets and name badges talking outdoors engaged in a casual group discussion.
    via Small Group Network

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • The property manager tried to steal everyone's security deposits, so we organized a tenant union and sued them collectively

    I live in a complex with about 40 units, and for years, the management has been getting away with daylight robbery.
    via 8CinderRhapsody
  • Every time someone moved out, they would hit them with a flat $500 "cleaning and administrative fee" regardless of how clean the apartment was.
    via 8CinderRhapsody
  • Most people just paid it or let it go because they didn't have the time or money to fight a corporate landlord in court.
    via 8CinderRhapsody
  • But last month, they tried to do it to three families at the same time, and we finally had enough.
    via 8CinderRhapsody
  • We started a simple group chat and realized that this was a systemic pattern of exploitation.
    via 8CinderRhapsody

  • Three families got hit at the same time, someone made a chat, and people started comparing notes. That is the moment the whole operation falls apart, because once you stop seeing it as bad luck or a strict manager and start seeing it as a deliberate pattern, the conversation changes entirely. Suddenly you are not one exhausted person staring down a corporate legal team over a principle. You are forty units with a lawyer who does this for a living.

  • We weren't just dealing with "bad luck" or a "strict" manager; we were dealing with a business model designed to siphon money from the working class.
    via 8CinderRhapsody
  • We organized a formal tenant union and pooled our resources to hire a lawyer who specializes in tenant rights.
    via 8CinderRhapsody
  • Group of adults chatting indoors, one woman holding paper during casual networking conversation.
    via bethbapchurch

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • As soon as the management realized they weren't fighting one isolated, exhausted person but an organized block of tenants, their tone shifted completely.
    via 8CinderRhapsody
  • They went from being arrogant and dismissive to trying to "negotiate" individual settlements to break our solidarity.
    via 8CinderRhapsody

  • The individual settlement offers that came once management realized what they were dealing with are genuinely funny in retrospect. That move only makes sense if you think people can be re-isolated after they have already figured out that isolation was the point. It is like a magician explaining the trick and then trying to do the trick again.

  • We stood our ground. We filed a collective action, and yesterday we won. The judge ruled that their flat- fee policy was illegal and ordered them to return every cent plus legal fees.
    via 8CinderRhapsody
  • This is why solidarity matters. Landlords rely on our isolation to exploit us. They want us to think we are alone and powerless against their lawyers and contracts.
    via 8CinderRhapsody
  • But housing is a human right, and when we organize, we can actually win against these parasites.
    via 8CinderRhapsody

  • The judge ruled the policy illegal. Every dollar came back plus legal fees. Which is why this whole saga is a pretty clean illustration of how a lot of exploitative systems stay in place for as long as they do. Not because they are unbeatable but because they are designed to be annoying to fight individually. The moment that changes, the bet stops paying out.


     

  • If you are going through this, talk to your neighbors. Your power is in your numbers.
    via 8CinderRhapsody
  • Talon_4Parallax This is the way. Seeing collective action actually work is so satisfying.
    via 8CinderRhapsody
  • 8CinderRhapsody Original Poster's Reply The best part was when they realized we werent backing down for individual payoffs. They tried to buy a few of us off early on but the group chat kept everyone focused. Solidarity really is their biggest fear.
    via 8CinderRhapsody
  • PrismCartographer A flat $500 fee regardless of condition is such a blatant scam. I am glad the judge saw through that garbage. Most people just eat the cost because legal fees are higher than the deposit, so pooling resources was a genius move. This should be a manual for every renter out there.
    via 8CinderRhapsody
  • 8CinderRhapsody Original Poster's Reply Winning felt so good. It was never about the money, just the principle.
    via 8CinderRhapsody
  • Glimm3rCairn Landlords really do rely on us being too tired or broke to fight back. The second they tried to negotiate individually to break your solidarity, you knew you had them scared. Hope that property manager enjoys writing those checks back to everyone. Love to see parasites losing in court.
    via 8CinderRhapsody
  • Trini1113 When I moved out of my last apartment complex (2015) and we were running late, the manager said "if you don't want to clean, we'll charge a flat $75". Granted, she liked us (we'd made her job easy for 10 years) and she also wanted to do the walkthrough and have it over with, but I was more than happy to pay that. But even accounting for a decade of inflation, $500 is excessive even if you did no cleaning at all. And if I had cleaned and still been charged a cleaning fee I'd have been l
    via 8CinderRhapsody
  • V4ctorGalleon The shift in their tone as soon as a lawyer gets involved is always hilarious. They act tough until they realize they cant bu y an entire group of people at once. Huge win for you and your neighbors!
    via 8CinderRhapsody
  • Hosstar881 Unions work!
    via 8CinderRhapsody
  • AutoModerator Landlords HATE THEM! Learn this one weird trick that leechlords don't want you to know about.. Organize your neighbors and form a tenants union. Check out this site to see if there is already a tenants union in your area. Visit our partnered sub, r/tenantunion, for more discussion regarding tenants unions and to see if there is an ATUN affiliated union near you. If you want to start your own or are already in one, reach out to become affiliated with ATUN! I am a bot, and this actio
    via 8CinderRhapsody
  • smuckola well said. Every time I see a story about good tenant organization, I see that the tenants all live in one complex. Thus, the landleeches that own houses located around a city benefit from the fact that house tenants don't know that each other exists at all! I know how to search my county tax website for all properties owned by the same person but I'm shy.
    via 8CinderRhapsody
  • MoreRamenPls !gif Power to the people!!
    via 8CinderRhapsody

Like what you see? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google. 

Tags

landlord winning property
Scroll Down For The Next Article

Also From FAIL Blog

15+ Employees who made huge mistakes on the job: 'Accidentally sent a company-wide email complaining about the boss'

15+ Employees who made huge mistakes on the job: 'Accidentally sent a company-wide email complaining about the boss'

Trending Now

Boss issues formal warning to employee during her approved vacation in Cabo for missing a meeting added to her work calendar while she was out of the country

Boss issues formal warning to employee during her approved vacation in Cabo for missing a meeting added to her work calendar while she was out of the country

01
23-year-old contributing to groceries and chores refuses to start paying rent while older brother lives for free at home: 'I made it very clear to my parents'

23-year-old contributing to groceries and chores refuses to start paying rent while older brother lives for free at home: 'I made it very clear to my parents'

02
19-year-old employee gets called to boss's office and told off for refusing to come in on a day off, employee holds his ground: ‘Why should I be expected to come in?’

19-year-old employee gets called to boss's office and told off for refusing to come in on a day off, employee holds his ground: ‘Why should I be expected to come in?’

03
20-year-old traveler leaves chronically late friend behind at a gas station after repeated delays, makes her flight and learns to stop over-accommodating: 'I’m not missing a flight'

20-year-old traveler leaves chronically late friend behind at a gas station after repeated delays, makes her flight and learns to stop over-accommodating: 'I’m not missing a flight'

04
Clever homeowner gets even with mean neighbor, makes the entire neighborhood more accessible while neighbor loses 42 inches of lawn space

Clever homeowner gets even with mean neighbor, makes the entire neighborhood more accessible while neighbor loses 42 inches of lawn space

05
'I can't keep it to myself anymore': 35-year-old millennial engineer claims that older employees are making their work "impossible"

'I can't keep it to myself anymore': 35-year-old millennial engineer claims that older employees are making their work "impossible"

06
Advertisement